National Affairs: Test of Religion

  • Share
  • Read Later

(3 of 3)

Democratic National Chairman Henry M. ("Scoop") Jackson hinted darkly that Republican moneybags were bankrolling the anti-Catholic campaign, and challenged the press to find out "who prepared the statement issued by Dr. Peale's group." He suggested that the issue was turning the whole campaign in Kennedy's favor. Ex-President Harry Truman charged that back home in Independence, Mo. "the Republicans are sending out all the dirty pamphlets they can find on the religious issue." Republican National Chairman Thruston Morton rebutted in the same vein: "The Democrats are deliberately keeping the religious issue alive for the purpose of exploiting it for their own political advantage. Former President Truman's statement that Republican headquarters are issuing anti-Catholic pamphlets is completely false and reprehensible."

Whose Gain? Candidate Kennedy, flying into Manhattan to accept the Liberal Party's endorsement, convulsed the dinner by declaring that the Republican platform should be entitled "The Power of Positive Thinking."* Invading heavily industrial New Jersey, he got one of the greatest receptions of any candidate in memory.

Politicians in both camps agreed that Kennedy stood to gain from the religion furor—so long as a counterreaction did not set in out of suspicion that he was deliberately exploiting it. Some Protestant Democrats might be roused to vote against him on the basis of religion alone in the farm belt and in the Deep South. But in the populous industrial states that he needs most of all—New York (35% Catholic), New Jersey (43%), Pennsylvania (31%), Illinois (33%), Michigan (24%), Ohio (21%), Wisconsin (32%)—Kennedy stands a good chance of winning, if he can solidify the Democratic Catholic vote that swung to Eisenhower in 1952 and 1956.† Nixon, on the other hand, feels that if religion does not become the decisive point in a voter's mind, he has a good chance of carrying such predominantly Catholic groups as the Poles and Hungarians, on the issue of "standing up to the Russians." Nixon's hold on conservative Catholic Republicans is strong, but TIME correspondents last week detected some movement away from Nixon into the "undecided" sector, under the force of the religion debate.

Religion was a subject that, most everyone agreed, had to be talked out at some point in the campaign, and sincere men as well as bigots had brought it to the fore. And it was also a question that could be talked about too much, to the exclusion of other important matters in 1960.

* Other humor making the rounds in Catholic circles: Kennedy wins the presidency, and in the normal course of events the time comes to elect a new Pope. "How about America's Cardinal Spellman?" suggests one Italian cardinal. "Not on your life," snaps a second. "Do you want the Vatican to be run from the White House?"

† Last week the Gallup Poll reported that 71% of U.S. Catholic voters lean toward Kennedy, 26% toward Nixon, with 3% undecided.

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. Next Page