(2 of 3)
Most of the ministers were impressed if not converted. "Martin Luther himself would have welcomed Senator Kennedy and cheered him," said a Lutheran, the Rev. George C. Reck. But some were unfazed. "Senator Kennedy is either a poor Catholic or he is stringing the people along," said Dr. W. A. Criswell, pastor of the nation's largest Southern Baptist congregation, who believes that a Catholic President is only the first step, until finally comes the day when "religious history has also died in America as it has died in Spain." The Kennedy camp rated Kennedy's performance as highly successfuland highly important in a state where he and Nixon are thought to be running neck and neck. Kennedy men planned to send tapes of the show to TV stations throughout the South and Midwest.
Cutoff. Early in the week, Dick Nixon proposed that both candidates keep the religion issue out of the Page One headlines by agreeing to a "cutoff date on its discussion." For himself, Nixon intended to begin the cutoff immediately, although he acknowledged that it would be more difficult for Kennedy to do so, and he rested on his often-repeated position that "I disapprove of the religious issue being used in my behalf or against my opponent." But he resisted demands from Democratic quarters that he denounce the implied endorsement of the Citizens for Religious Freedomincluding such prominent Protestant preachers as Dr. Norman Vincent Peale and Dr. Daniel A. Polingwhich had questioned the Kennedy candidacy on religious grounds.
Hapless Dr. Peale, for once not seeming Everyman's best guide to Confident Living (one of his multimillion-selling titles), tried to separate himself from the movement he had made himself the spokesman for. The Philadelphia Inquirer dropped his weekly column. Dr. Peale emerged from a week-long "retreat," after offering to resign from the pulpit of Manhattan's Marble Collegiate Church (refused), and submitting his resignation from the Citizens for Religious Freedom (accepted), and he declared that the people have a right to elect a man of any religionor none at allto the presidency. "I was not duped, I was just stupid," he told a New York Herald Tribune reporter.
"Magnificent." The so-called Citizens for Religious Freedom, which had set the whole fuss going the week before, praised Kennedy's Houston statement as "the most complete, unequivocal and reassuring statement which could be expected of any person in his position." "Magnificent," echoed Dr. Daniel A. Poling. In the October issue of the Christian Herald, which he edits, Dr. Poling explained why he got into the public controversy in the first place. "Religion is important in an election because it is important, or should be important, to the man who practices it. Anything that helps to make the man is important to voters when that man runs for public office and particularly for the highest office in the land."
