Amanda Overmyer
You Can't Do That
Idol's vocal coaches pull off the amazing feat of finding a Beatles song—the B-side of Can't Buy Me Love—that neither the audience nor the singer have ever heard before. But it turns out to be a good choice; belting out a simple R&B song the audience has no preconceptions about lets Amanda put her own stamp on it. Even if that stamp has Janis Joplin's initials on it.