(2 of 3)
The case boiled down to the most fundamental question that faces America's constitutional form of governance: To what extent can society enforce its standards without infringing too far on the rights of those in the minority? Rehnquist provided a classic formulation of the conservative position: "Surely one of the high purposes of a democratic society is to legislate against conduct that is regarded as evil and profoundly offensive to the majority of people." Brennan offered the liberal response: "If there is a bedrock principle underlying the First Amendment, it is that the Government may not prohibit the expression of an idea simply because society finds the idea itself offensive or disagreeable."
The court's decision was based on the premise that burning the flag was a form of symbolic speech. "We decline," Brennan wrote, "to create for the flag an exception to the joust of principles protected by the First Amendment." Such a decision does not denigrate the flag, he argued. "Our decision is a reaffirmation of the principles of freedom and inclusiveness that the flag best reflects."
Kennedy's concurrence obviously caused him anguish. "The flag holds a lonely place of honor in an age when absolutes are distrusted," he noted. Nevertheless, Kennedy concluded, "it is poignant but fundamental that the flag protects those who hold it in contempt."
Rehnquist rejected the premise that flag burning was a form of symbolic speech, calling it the "equivalent of an inarticulate grunt or roar." In his separate dissent, Stevens made the case that the flag as a symbol is "worthy of protection from unnecessary desecration." He cited a variety of cases where the Government might legitimately restrict free expression in order to protect other interests: the writing of graffiti on the Washington Monument, painting or projecting movie messages on the Lincoln Memorial, extinguishing the eternal flame at John Kennedy's grave.
Acts of vandalism such as these clearly are not protected by the court's ruling. Likewise, not all flag burning is protected. A person who attacks Old Glory flying over a public building could still be charged with vandalism, trespassing or other crimes. If the burning of a flag would "tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace," that too could still be considered a crime. As Oliver Wendell Holmes might have said, freedom of speech does not give a person the right to set a flag on fire in a crowded theater.
The ruling does, however, invalidate laws in 48 states (the exceptions are Alaska and Wyoming) and at the federal level that prohibit the desecration of the flag. It also presumably would have protected the provocative display at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago at which, earlier this year, an American flag was placed on the floor, where viewers might step on it.
