(3 of 3)
Most of the actors in the film do not deserve the plaudits they won on the stage. Leif Erikson plays the husband as such a dumb galoot that it is impossible to believe that a sensitive girl like Deborah would ever have married him. John Kerr puts remarkably little imagination into the part of the boy; it .often reads much better than he plays. it. Deborah Kerr, on the other hand, is excellent: always in scale, always in key. And Norma Crane does some wonderful flobbing around the screen as the slavey and general grab bag at the local hash house. 1984. (Holiday; Columbia). Things to come, as George Orwell saw them in his clever antitotalitarian tract, written in 1949, have assumed a horrifying political shape by 1984. The State is everything, terror is normalcy, love is a crime. Political shapes, however, are not the kind that lure millions to the movies, even in an election year. What's more, the camera has not yet been invented that can take a picture of an idea, and Orwell's book was a tissue of ideaseven his characters were no more than debaters' points, well made. For these reasons, the producers of this picture decided to play down, as far as possible, the subtle political angles, play up the obvious physiological curves of a handsome blonde actress named Jan Sterling. Result: a serious political satire comes off the screen as a sort of tractor romance in reverse, an anti-Communist soap opera that might more aptly have been titled Life Can Be Ugly. Orwell's book was depressing, partly because it was far too slick, but this film is far more depressing. The people who made it seem to have slipped on Orwell's slickness, and fallen flat on their faces.
