As a rule, novels are supposed to end when the heroine is brutally raped and murdered. Then again, a delicate, devastatingly sad literary novel isn't supposed to knock Tom Clancy off the bestseller lists this year, either. Sebold's novel follows a murdered suburban teenager into heaven, from which celestial vantage point she observes the aftermath of her tragedy. It's a luminous, lyrical performance that hits the heart like a sledgehammer. Rules, like hearts, and sales records, were made to be broken.
(Fiction)
The Piano Man conquers Broadway, Eminem goes Hollywood, plus the rest of TIME's picks for the best of the year