On Jan. 2, 2010, just hours after being profiled on America's Most Wanted, Paul Michael Merhige was found and arrested for allegedly gunning down four family members at a Thanksgiving Day gathering. A monthlong manhunt for Merhige had proved fruitless, but authorities received a tip to his location after owners of the Edgewater Lodge in Long Key, Fla., saw a preview of the crime show's upcoming segment and recognized Merhige as a man who had recently checked into their motel. Merhige is just one of 1,100 suspected criminals caught as a result of their appearances on the show.