Prince Alvarado, an aspiring DJ wanted for allegedly shooting four people outside a New Jersey White Castle in August 2006, managed to evade the cops for three years. But after AMW featured him on Nov. 14, 2009, police nabbed Alvarado within hours. In the wee hours of Nov. 15, they stormed the Florida apartment where he had reportedly been living with his girlfriend under the alias Nelson T. Holliday, working as a telemarketer and selling sneakers out of his car. "It seems hard to believe that it happened so fast," said Inspector Rick Cope of the U.S. Marshals. "People really do call in and give you valuable tips." Alvarado faces four counts of attempted murder and criminal weapons offenses.