David Archuleta
You're the Voice
OK, it's not like I expected David A. to sing Nirvana. But surely there were better choice from 1991 than this corny midtempo anthem (which was first recorded in 1985 anyway). And Simon's right, David's Up-With-People performance seems awkward and devoid of connection. But his voice is strong as usual; given that, and given that he did not kill a puppy onstage, the Magic Unicorn of Cuteness will protect him again this week nonetheless.
— by James Poniewozik