David Cook
Eleanor Rigby
The same emo-rock treatment that turned Lionel Richie's Hello into gold wows the judges, with Paula pronouncing David a "dark horse" and Simon saying he could win the whole thing. I don't get it, even though David is one of my favorites. It's a good vocal, but if there's one thing Rigby doesn't need, it's *more* pathos. But I guess I'm one of the lonely people on this one.