Alexandrea Lushington
If You Leave Me Now
Another gender change — "Oooooh, boy, I just want you to stay" — but I'll forgive it for the fact that she managed to make something sweet and thoughtful of a white-bread elevator ballad by one of the corniest bands of all time. The judges knock her for a "boring" performance, but I actually think they're criticizing the song, and I give her points at least for changing up the arrangement.