After managing Richard Nixon's presidential campaign, Mitchell was appointed head of the Department of Justice. While there, he backed two Supreme Court nominees that were deemed unqualified, approved unconstitutional wiretaps, prosecuted anti-war protesters and was involved in the famed Pentagon Papers suit. It was an ignominious reign (on its own, enough, perhaps, to merit inclusion on this list), but Mitchell wasn't done. In 1974, he was indicted for conspiring to plan the Watergate break-in and for perjuring himself during the ensuing cover-up. Convicted the following year, he served 19 months in prison.
Top 10 Worst Cabinet Members
Sometimes those purported to be the best and the brightest are anything but. In the spirit of not making the same mistakes twice, TIME examines some of modern history's less-than-fabulous Cabinet appointments