Hit Me Up
This is probably Syesha's worst vocal but best performance of the night: she finally seems to loosen up and, as they say on Idol, "have a good time" onstage. I still feel, though, that I'm watching her Broadway audition more than her attempt to win American idol.
by James Poniewozik
Mercado's first song: If I Ain't Got You|
Mercado's second song: Fever
Next David Cook