True story: my wife, a.k.a. Mrs. Tuned In, predicted weeks ago that Archuleta would break the Dan Fogelberg barrier on Idol, and tonight the producers made her dream come true. Three decades after the '70s, this ballad still pours like molasses, and David A. turns it into the prettiest love song an elf ever sang to a unicorn.
by James Poniewozik
Archuleta's first song: And So It Goes|
Archuleta's second song: With You
Next Syesha Mercado