Light My Fire
Johns channels Eddie Vedder more than Jim Morrison, but you know Paula can't resist: "You really did set the night on fire!" He's easily the most polished singer of the night, but you'd hope so given that, at 29, he's old enough to adopt David Archuleta. Overall, the guys were...guys. A few have promise, but most look like easy prey for the far more talented girls come ousting time.
Next The Top 24