Now more than ever in movie romance, when two people are in love, one has to die. Here, it's perfect hubby Gerard Butler, leaving his widow Hilary Swank in a sluice of grief. The film's odd perkiness is undone by its noble sentimentality, making this less a chick flick than an ick flick. See it only if you're in the mood for prime cornography.
Next Grand Theft Auto IV