BEST NEW PILOT
The CW, 9/13
It's Sarah Michelle Gellar's TV comeback--or rather, comebacks. In this noirish thriller, the former Buffy plays Bridget, a recovering drug addict, as well as Siobhan, her estranged, wealthy twin. When Siobhan goes missing and is presumed dead, Bridget decides to try on her life for size. Can Gellar slay personal demons as well as she did vampires?
UP ALL NIGHT
If you're watching TV because your newborn has finally fallen asleep in your lap and you don't dare move, this is the show for you. Starring Christina Applegate and Will Arnett as...